Guest Stars Rya Kihlstedt as Sandy Walker Camila Perez as Alison M.C. Gainey as Wyatt Wilson Jane McLean as Lisa Wilson Julian Acosta as Jeffrey Manning Shane Paul McGhie as Shawn Co Starring Toby Marks as Nicole Davis Lucy Savage as Sarah Manning Tessa Alison Blaire as Lizzy Manning Tommy Schiltz as Older Devin Walker Dante Rice as Older Phil Walker Matt McKinney as Server