Guest Stars Patrick Gallagher as Sheriff Walter Tubb Brooke Smith as Merrilee Legarski Sharon Taylor as Commander Elena Sosa Alessandro Juliani as Dr. Wang Karin Konoval as Penelope Denesuk John Kapelos as Father Ted Maynard Sara Canning as Rachel Westergaard Evan Whitten as Erik Westergaard Co Starring Raugi Yu as Polygrapher Michael Meneer as Male Desk Anchor Guy Fauchon as Deputy on Guard Tanja Dixon-Warren as Store Owner Kristina Matisic as Female Desk Anchor Tenaj Williams as News Reporter