Special Guest Stars Joe Mantegna voices Fat Tony Megan Mullally voices Sarah Wiggum Nick Offerman voices Captain Bowditch Tiya Sircar voices Bette Natasha Rothwell voices Erin Bob Seger voices Himself Guest Stars Alex Désert voices Carl Carlson Maggie Roswell voices Helen Lovejoy Maggie Roswell voices Luanne Van Houten Tress MacNeille voices Lindsey Naegle Tony Rodriguez voices Julio Franco Dawnn Lewis voices Bernice Hibbert Pamela Hayden voices Ladies Chris Edgerly voices Guys