Guest Stars Lucia Ryan as Benedetta Rohr John Doman as Guy Dan Blake Baumgartner as Kick Ryan Pernell Walker as Grace Campbell Keiko Elizabeth as U.S. Attorney Karen Shimizu Kameron Kierce as Kelvin Campbell Leon as Reverend Isaiah Hughes Michael O'Keefe as Agent Clasby Owen Laheen as Maeve Regan James Michael Cummings as Tommy Hayes Shannon Wallace as Anton Campbell Fedna Jacquet as Dr. Callie Mack Mike Doyle as Josh Goshen Carrie Compere as Nia Townsend Roy Jackson as James Wright Betsy Beutler as Susan Donald Billy Smith as Sean Foley Co Starring Grayson Eddey as Tony Ryan Nora Murphy as Marie Ryan Elizabeth Stahlmann as Holly Gunner Ann Arvia as Lisa Paelli Christian Maverick White as Isaac Turner Marc John Jefferies as Rickey Townsend Amyrh Harris as Trey Parker Zoe Zien as Customer #1 Kyle Mara as Customer #2