Guest Stars Oscar Montoya voices David Drew Tarver voices Charles Lee Jeremy Rowley voices Jimmy Lee Michelle Buteau voices Biscuit Grandma Chris Diamantopoulos voices Minister Mikey David Herman voices Jason David Herman voices Nerdy Businessman David Herman voices Easter Bunny David Herman voices Trashy Guy JP Karliak voices Another Man Phil LaMarr voices Announcer Grey DeLisle Griffin voices Tawny Grey DeLisle Griffin voices Teen 2 Grey DeLisle Griffin voices Greeter Sarah Baker voices Pastor Joanne Drew Tarver voices Man Oscar Montoya voices Teen 3 Jeremy Rowley voices Guy