Guest Stars Jennifer Landon as Sarah Allen James Carpinello as Hugh Hill Paula Jon DeRose as Claudia D'Ambrose Mike Houston as Sheriff Lancaster Brent Langdon as Mayor Castro John Carlin as Greg Krohl Co Starring Rodrigo Luzzi as Bartender J.J. Pyle as Cheryl Rhodes Charlie Kevin as Officer Helms Monica Giordano as Sidney Mann Zachary Le Vey as Rodney D'Ambrose Sean Ricciardi as Jerome Powell Luis Carlos de la Lombana as Phil Gomez Sean Kaufman as Teenager Candice Jean-Jacques as Brenda Gomez Kasey Buckley as Detective Marks Andy Zimmerman as Park Ranger Jeff Woods Garlin as Lieutenant Kane Max Santopietro as Eli Jacobs Laura Lamberti as Realtor Phil Schneider as Bryan Castro Caroline Grogan as Tessa Lancaster Kaleb Wells as Danny Rhodes Keilah Wolk as Anissa Gomez Max Schochet as Derek Krohl Katie Lombardo as Jane Armstrong