Guest Stars Jennifer Landon as Sarah Allen James Carpinello as Hugh Hill Victor Williams as Moses Reid Michael Drayer as Evan Greeter David Aaron Baker as Buck Allen Larisa Polonsky as Maggie Shawn Parsons as Ray Kite / Clayton Smith Tracy McMullan as Susan Kleinman Co Starring Anne Rutter as Gemma Greeter DeShawn Harold Mitchell as PD Officer J. Stephen Brantley as Earl Teren Carter as Elwood Lauriel Friedman as Elise Shalet Tim Shelburne as Jason Shalet