Guest Stars Liam McIntyre as Clarke Wendell Pat Healy as Marty Dixon John Patrick Jordan as Earl Kim Shaw as Carol Lynn Denton Abbie Cobb as Nat Dixon Dirk Rogers as Miss Vera Bailey Noble as Marlene Malcolm M. Mays as Calvin Brooke Smith as Helen Koistra Dale Dickey as The Woman Lindsey Kraft as Midge Pruitt Max Barsness as Dale Pruitt Co Starring Peyton Nicole Morton as Nancy Allyson Dixon as Bus Stop Girl Mia Komsky as Dina Zakary Shawn Risinger as Tommy Jon Ryckman as Sears Delivery Man Natalie Britton as Dottie Ilana Becker as Greta