Guest Stars Carlos Aviles as Mick Lauren Lapkus as Agent Phoebe Donnegan Jonathan Silverman as Dave Sally Pressman as Nancy Niko Nicotera as Gene Dave Theune as Eric Chelsea Alden as Penny Co Starring Everleigh McDonell as Jane Boland Kevin Nichols as New Security Guard Aaron Aguilera as Burly Owner Van Epperson as Elderly Man Sarah Benoit as Haggard Old Woman William Christian as Store Owner Johnny Hoops as Terrified Man