Guest Stars Jazzy Kae as Anna Baker Matt Dellapina as Eric Rentzel Amy Hohn as Judge Sally Volk Megan Channell as Rachel Ness Stacey Sargeant as ADA Barrett Hadi Tabbal as Brooks Boseman Danny Mastrogiorgio as Josh Shoemaker Mairin Lee as NYPD Officer Pearce Jaime Lincoln Smith as Levi Hartwell Kaden Alexander Hughes as Callum Hartwell Co Starring Ollie Robinson as Mauricio Rentzel Amy Hayes as Juror #27 Yamilah Saravong as Vanessa Phillips Chengusoyane Kargbo as Juror #13 Quentin Nguyen-Duy as Man / Victor Phillips