Guest Stars Tom Verica as Sam Keating Arjun Gupta as Kan Lenny Platt as Griffin O'Reilly Alysia Reiner as D.A. Wendy Parks Elliot Knight as Aiden Walker John Getz as David Dolan David Denman as Kevin Murphy Jason Gedrick as Gabriel Shaw Ana Ortiz as Paula Murphy Patrick J. McGuire as Jailer #2 Co Starring Eva La Dare as Leah James McAndrew as Clayton Joshua Wolf Coleman as Ted Juan Alfonso as Jailer Rick Gifford as Prosecutor Kal Bennett as FBI Agent Steven M. Gagnon as Officer James Nelson Tom Beyer as Trent Davis Mehdi Merali as Parking Attendant Katherine Kirkpatrick as Alice Joni Bovill as Judge Danny Fehsenfeld as Athletic Director Uma Incrocci as Secretary Donna Rusch as Annoyed Detective