Special Guest Stars Griffin Dunne as Nick Pearson Melanie Liburd as Zoe Guest Stars Rachel Hilson as Teenage Beth Timothy Omundson as Gregory Stephen Friedrich as Jordan Martin Foster Dan Lauria as Mr. Damon Stephen Guarino as James Co Starring Ellie Griffitts as VI Choir Natane Latimore as VI Choir Allie Elliott as VI Singer #1 Ava Tenerelli as Courtney Cicely Morales as VI Choir Riya Golakeia as VI Choir Zoey Serrato as VI Choir Jocelyn Riddle as Amelia Aubrey Brock as VI Choir #2 Melissa Center as Landlady Jeanette O'Connor as Vicky Ying Sayun as Lawyer Alexi Pappas as Talent Assistant Kamala López-Dawson as Markie Gavin Stevens as VI Choir #5