Guest Stars Lauren Lapkus as Agent Phoebe Donnegan Jonathan Silverman as Dave Noureen DeWulf as Krystal / Diane Shane Coffey as Kevin Breckin Meyer as Vance Madison Ignacio Serricchio as Nick Martin Rodney To as Agent Henry Jordan Belfi as Z Ever Carradine as Denise Carpenter Shelley Robertson as Officer Shel Johnson Co Starring Antonimar Murphy as Mercedes Michelle Costello as Heaven Mia Hunt as Waitress Keylor Leigh as Angela Archer Moller as Garett Heart Hayes as Porsche Aaron Fili as Mr. Keller Catherine Kresge as Julie Nikea Gamby-Turner as Councilmember Jim Blanchette as Mr. Sambroski Tony von Halle as Nate Regina Fernandez as Mom Amber Dancy as Janet