Guest Stars Merrin Dungey as Officer Sonya Harris Brian Oblak as James Reiben Patricia Belcher as Loretta Jasmine Ashanti as Makayla Williams Co Starring Mandy June Turpin as Dr. Jessica Lamotte Nicky Endres as CSI Tech Veronica Burgess as Officer Mangieri Karl Herlinger as Logan McCarthy Barry Brisco as Harry Ian McQuown as Caroler #2 Peter Xifo as Santa Claus Eboni Adams as Caroler #1 Kelsey Hainlen as Caroler #3