Special Guest Stars Vincent Kartheiser as Jonathan Crane / Scarecrow Guest Stars Karen Robinson as Margarita Vee McKinley Freeman as Justin Colt Wendy Crewson as Valeska Nox Co Starring Rose Napoli as Trina Holmes Anthony J. Mifsud as Santiago Perez Al McFoster as Rafelson Roberts Miranda Calderon as Ann Williams Naomi Wright as Bank Teller Mal Dassin as Telly Rupp Ted Ludzik as Prison Guard Danny Smith as Tod Olivia Barrett as News Reporter Michael Dufays as Spiderweb Face Afton Rentz as Goldcaps Ilan Rosenberg as Scarface