Guest Stars Elizabeth Scopel as Sarah Fier Gillian Jacobs as C. Berman Matthew Zuk as Mayor Will Goode Keil Oakley Zepernick as "Shame Killer" Isaac Milton Emily Brobst as Billy Barker Michael Chandler as "The Pastor" Cyrus Miller Kevin Waterman as "The Milkman" Harry Rooker Charlene Amoia as Rachel Thompson / Sunnyvale Customer Todd Allen Durkin as Officer Kapinski Jeremy Ford as Peter Lacy Camp as Mrs. Fraser Lloyd Pitts as Nightwing Killer Noah Garrett as Skull Mask Jaime Matthis as Shadyside Player Eric Mendenhall as Nurse Beddy Jana Allen as TV Reporter #1 Matt Burke as Football Coach David Thompson as Ryan Torres Christian Bridges as Fun Shadyside Football Player Danyon Huntington as Sunnyvale Skullmask Tayla Rogers as Babysitting Twin Maya Rogers as Babysitting Twin Diane Sellers as Check In Nurse Meghan Packer as TV Reporter #2
