Guest Stars Elizabeth Scopel as Sarah Fier Matthew Zuk as Mayor Will Goode Julia Rehwald as Kate Schmidt Fred Hechinger as Simon Kalivoda Keil Oakley Zepernick as "Shame Killer" Isaac Milton Emily Brobst as Billy Barker Kevin Waterman as "The Milkman" Harry Rooker Michael Chandler as "The Pastor" Cyrus Miller Meghan Packer as TV Anchor Michael Provost as Kurt Drew Scheid as Gary Kenneth Trujillo as EMT Marcelle LeBlanc as Becky Jacqi Vene as Joan Dylan Gage as Jeremy Lana Spraley as Shadyside Prisoner #1 Sam Brooks as Arnie Jayden Griffin as Cool Sunnyvale Camper Alex Huff as Mean Sunnyvale Jailor Eden Campbell as Annie Brandon Spink as Young Will Goode Paul Teal as Young Officer Kapinski Jason Edwards as Sunnyvale Cop Ja'rell Anderson as Shadyside Prisoner #2
