Guest Stars Carlos Aviles as Mick Lauren Lapkus as Agent Phoebe Donnegan Jonathan Silverman as Dave Shane Coffey as Kevin Breckin Meyer as Vance Madison Ignacio Serricchio as Nick Martin Andrew McCarthy as James Fitzpatrick Jerod Haynes as Cory Todd Robert Anderson as Johnny Robert Jumper as Eddy Co Starring Mia Hunt as Waitress Kandiss Crone as Local Reporter Tessa Bartholomew as Local News Reporter Sam Gregory as Addict Girl Jeremy Denzlinger as Manager / Cop Aisha Lomax as Cashier / Paramedic Erika Bowman as Mom