Special Guest Stars Kathleen York as Joy Mason Guest Stars Ana Ayora as Sarah Hughes Dewshane Williams as Trey Williams Alan van Sprang as Chief Detective Keith Alper Maurice Compte as Josiah Julie Khaner as Superintendent Kate Simmons Paula Brancati as Hannah Stonage Paul Braunstein as Officer Dennis Brandt Cynthia Jimenez-Hicks as Erin Co Starring Claudia Jurt as Cindy