Guest Stars Charles Melton as Wyatt Danny Trejo as Santa Kevin McHale as Barry Taneka Johnson as Detective Deena Gibbs Dyllón Burnside as James Nico Greetham as Zinn Co Starring Gail Rastorfer as Irate Mom #1 Brady Reiter as Teenage Girl Elf Josh Latzer as Super Michelle Costello as Girl Kevin Thompson as Little Person Elf Chuck Spitler as Mall Santa Steve Schriver as Businessman Rowland Akinduro as D.J. Cary Christopher as Little Boy Maria Carmen as Irate Mom #2