Guest Stars Ciara Renée voices Abbey Peter Scolari as Bishop Thomas Marx Kristen Connolly as Detective Mira Byrd Darren Pettie as Orson LeRoux Jessie Mueller as Anya Fredric Lehne as Mick Carr Corey Cott as Officer Jim Turley Wayne Duvall as Louie Wolff Co Starring Ron Scott as Postal Carrier Brett Bartholomew as Cop #2 (with David) Tom Lucca as Cop #2 (Video) Eddie Boroevich as Cop #1 (Video) Aaron Phillips as Cop #1 (with Ben) Anna Crivelli as Female Cop (Video) Ryan Black as Officer Cliff Locke