Guest Stars Robin Bartlett as Cathy Sarayu Blue as Miriam Allan Wasserman as Rabbi Sherman Rob Brownstein as Rabbi Goldberg Co Starring Gable Swanlund as Nancy Lee Bachrach as Lizzie Richard Aaron Anderson as Joel Annie Karstens as Marty's Mother, Lillian Eric James Satterberg as Videographer Chase Brosamle as Young Marty Maya Bednarek as Young Phyllis Christopher Wallinger as Marty's Father Kenny Ellis as Cantor Robert Buscemi as Bandleader Yong Kim as Korean Grocer, Byung-Joon Mike Rad as Leroy Taylor Coleman as Emily Goldschmidt David J. Castillo as Bar Mitzvah DJ