Guest Stars Robby Ramos as Diego Cottonmouth Trey Tucker as Bobby Pin Marcia DeBonis as Debbie Joel Murray as Eddie Earl Eliza Coyle as Annie Earl Duke Davis Roberts as Big Jim Kitchen Alice Barrett Mitchell as Carol David James Elliott as Tom "King" Spade Perry Hawx as Denny the Ref CM Punk as Ricky Rabies Erica Pappas as Melanie Kitchen Danielle Gross as Courtney Katie Carpenter as Kate Di Quon as Flight attendant Ryann Redmond as Whitney Elliott Dixon as Tony Bonnie Somerville as Vicky Rabies Bob Banks as Old man / Roger Liz McGeever as Inebriated woman (Terri) Erin Ownbey as Tawny Chase Steven Anderson as Waiter John Siciliano as TBD Becca Potter as Cheryl Stone Garcia as Wolfgang