Guest Stars Robby Ramos as Diego Cottonmouth Trey Tucker as Bobby Pin Mike O'Malley as Charlie Gully Joel Murray as Eddie Earl Eliza Coyle as Annie Earl Duke Davis Roberts as Big Jim Kitchen Alice Barrett Mitchell as Carol Larry Clarke as Ted Day David James Elliott as Tom "King" Spade Erica Pappas as Melanie Kitchen Jaxon McHan as Young Ace Mason Gillett as Young Ace Zoe Myers as Diane Spencer Garrett as Pastor Heery Mick Foley as Dick Valentino Leydi Morales as Waitress Elizabeth Maier as Therese Nathan Hunter as Football Kid #1 Owen Bedwell as Football Kid #2 Roy Roberts as Randy