Guest Stars Damon Wayans Jr. as Ernie "Coach" Tagliaboo Gillian Vigman as Kim Mary Elizabeth Ellis as Caroline Joey Luthman as Walter Co Starring Lauren Dair Owens as Teen Jess David Neher as Benjamin Ian Wolterstorff as Spencer Hayley Marie Norman as Hot Hostess Ashton Swinford as Spencer Girl Jack Yang as Peter Andy Scott Harris as Groaning Boy Steve Bannos as Cab Driver Porter Kelly as Woman on Bike