Guest Stars Carina Battrick as Caroline Cross Barbara Alyn Woods as Michelle Cross Devon Sawa as Logan Wheeler Michael Therriault as Nathan Cross Lexa Doig as Bree Wheeler Rachelle Casseus as Detective Evans Travis Milne as Detective Peyton Co Starring Tyler Barish as Teen Charles Amber V. Cull as Smiley Woman / Mother Shem Joseph Maude as Red Headed Toddler Elinor Price as Mrs. Hayden Matthew Maenpaa as Mr. Hayden Mish Tam as Nurse #2 Rain Janjua as Nibs Mason Ward as Curly Ivano DiCaro as Tootles Vanessa Mitchell as Nurse #1 David Bronfman as Doctor Sarah Evans as House Mother Michael Scholar Jr. as Janitor