Guest Stars Fedna Jacquet as Charlotte Gaines Tonye Patano as Susan "Mama B" Barnes Jay Karnes as Cecil Walsh Eden Malyn as Nora Bryant Stephen Mark Lukas as Daniel Carter Philip Hernández as Mario Gomez Co Starring Raigan Olivia Newton as Anais Barnes-Gaines David Nash as Eli Bryant Eva Jette Putrello as Karlie Walsh Violet Adams as Amanda Walsh Cristala Carter as Rachel Morris Jenny Strassburg as Ellen Walsh Lizzy Plimpton as Shelly Lewis Nazario Maisonet as Neighbor Terrence Shingler as Liam Smith Brenda Crawley as Lauryn Harrison Allen Fawcett as Father Adam Jones David F.M. Vaughn as Dog Walker Dominique Nieves as Terrified Woman