Guest Stars Kaz Womack as Kevin (6 y/o) Isabella Rose Landau as Kate (6 y/o) Ca'ron Jaden Coleman as Randall (6 y/o) Adam Korson as Elijah La Trice Harper as Adult Déjà Andrew Santino as Casey Tobias Jelinek as David Watkins Co Starring Johnny Kincaid as Jack Jr. Hays McEachern as Young Dave Malone Kya Kruse as Young Rebecca Malone Allie Elliott as VI Singer #1 Natane Latimore as VI Choir Ellie Griffitts as VI Choir Ava Tenerelli as Courtney Cicely Morales as VI Choir Riya Golakeia as VI Choir Zoey Serrato as VI Choir Aubrey Brock as VI Choir #2 Tom Beyer as Magistrate Eileen Grubba as Mrs. Dunn Kristina Miller Weston as Masseuse Will Block as Assistant Jocelyn Riddle as VI Choir #6 Chris Jai Alex as Officer Jackson Andrea Nelson as Jess