Guest Stars Meredith Garretson as Kate Hawthorne Gary Farmer as Dan Twelvetrees Diana Bang as Nurse Ellen Jenna Lamia as Judy Cooper Gracelyn Awad Rinke as Sahar Nathan Fillion voices Octopus / No. 42 David Lewis as Mayor Mitch Co Starring Kaylayla Raine as Jay Trevor Carroll as John Lauren K. Robek as Laurie Eleanor Walker as Dr. Smallwood Eugene Brave Rock as Shane Lisa Chandler as Boater #2 Laara Sadiq as Bonnie Shaw Adam Chase as Boater #3 James Mowat as Boater #1 Rebecca Ferguson as Boater #4