Special Guest Stars Linda Hamilton as General McCallister Guest Stars Meredith Garretson as Kate Hawthorne Gary Farmer as Dan Twelvetrees Jenna Lamia as Judy Cooper Gracelyn Awad Rinke as Sahar Sarah Podemski as Kayla Mandell Maughan as Lisa Casper Justin Rain as Elliot Ben Cotton as Jimmy Nathan Fillion voices Octopus / No. 42 Michael Cassidy as Dr. Ethan Stone David Lewis as Mayor Mitch Tommy Pico as Drew Co Starring Kaylayla Raine as Jay Terry O'Quinn voices Peter Bach Paul Piaskowski as Robert Edna Manitowabi as Grandma Ruth Elle Rivas as Young D'Arcy Lini Evans as Bethany Bloom Barclay Hope as Gerald Bloom Grace Dove as Sunny Amber Lewis as Moira Russell Roberts as Social Worker Leif Havdale as Anonymous Man #2 V.G. Winter as Host Nathan Alexis as Big Leroy Samuel Smith as Anonymous Man #1 Kevin Saxby as Waiter Brendan Riley as Jay's Boyfriend