Guest Stars Rae Dawn Chong as Betty Currie Colin Hanks as Mike Emmick Judith Light as Susan Carpenter-McMillan Darren Goldstein as Jackie Bennett Mira Sorvino as Marcia Lewis Dan Bakkedahl as Ken Starr Taran Killam as Steve Jones Patrick Fischler as Sidney Blumenthal Scott Michael Morgan as Mike McCurry Lindsey Broad as Karin Immergut Joseph Mazzello as Paul Begala Ashlie Atkinson as Juanita Broaddrick Christopher Redman as Anthony Zaccagnini Co Starring Emma Malouff as Allison Tripp Jenny C. Paul as Susan Craig Welzbacher as Agent Irons Brian Maillard as Agent Fallon Jared Gertner as Sol Wisenberg Jim Rash as Ken Bacon Jamie Baer as Colleen Alan Starzinski as Brett Kavanaugh Aaron Coleman as Nathaniel Speights Tom Simmons as Willie Ryan Nassif as Ryan Tripp Warren Sweeney as Plato Cacheris Richard Wharton as Ponytail Juror Taneka Johnson as Forewoman Freda Alexander B Z Cullins as Court Security Officer Zachary Margulies as Aide Celestial as Elderly Female Juror Brandee Steger as Meticulous Juror Pamela Roberts as Woman in Burgundy Chanda Hartman as Juror in Earth Tones Suzanne H. Smart as Juror who looks like Kirstie Alley Jim Garrity as Jim Moran Cheryl Francis Harrington as Perplexed Woman LaSaundra Gibson as Reporter Outside Courthouse #2 Charley Flyte as Wincing Reporter Glenn Edward as CNN Interviewer Cat Elliott as Reporter Outside Courthouse #1 Monique Mosee as Ken Bacon's Secretary Ethan Hathaway as Residence Inn Son Nicholas Dubberley as Residence Inn Man Daniel Avidon as Accordian Player #2 Mary Corsetti as Reporter Outside Courthouse #3 Ira Scipio as FBI Agent Vick Sabian as Ron (Groundskeeper) Jason C. Daniels as Residence Inn Dad Don Frankel as Accordian Player #1 William Sterling as Reporter Outside Courthouse #3 Bamm Ericsen as Street Preacher Scott Mosenson as Dr. Loeb Julianne Buescher as Mary Anne Wirth