Guest Stars Jade Wu as Judge Cara Bergen Sharon Washington as Olivia Powell Patrick Breen as AUSA Parker Reilly Julie Dretzin as Carole Atkins J. Tucker Smith as Coach Randall Hughes Co Starring Charley Tucker as Juror #5 Frank Failla as Retired Postal Worker Alexandria Benford as Juror #4 Kedren Spencer as Agent Swerdlow J.D. Martin as F.B.I. Agent #1 Daniel Danielson as Juror #7 Caitlin Kerchner as Juror #2 Amy Lopatin as Preschool Teacher Josh Jeffers as I-Banker