Guest Stars John Early as Detective Culp Tiya Sircar as Jennifer #1 Kelvin Yu as Ned Conway Genevieve Angelson as Indigo Ayden Mayeri as Jennifer #2 Co Starring Christopher May as Mr. Shapiro Miracle Laurie as Quiet Heather Al Bayan as Classmate #1 Ashley Dulaney as Classmate #2 Danielle Juliet Ma as Classmate #3