Special Guest Stars Will Forte as Himself Guest Stars John Early as Detective Culp Tiya Sircar as Jennifer #1 Kelvin Yu as Ned Conway Genevieve Angelson as Indigo Ayden Mayeri as Jennifer #2 Everly Carganilla as Maggie Mel Rodriguez as Captain Ostrander Reid Scott as Aldrin Germain Fred Savage as Vaughn Co Starring Christopher May as Mr. Shapiro Miracle Laurie as Quiet Heather Owen Szabo as Caterer