Guest Stars Matilda Szydagis as Zelda Joel Johnstone as Archie Cleary Jane Lynch as Sophie Lennon Stephanie Hsu as Mei Reid Scott as Gordon Ford John Scurti as Nicky Gideon Glick as Alfie Erik Palladino as Frank Max Casella as Michael Kessler Jason Alexander as Asher Friedman James Monroe Iglehart as Charlie Kayli Carter as Gloria Santino Fontana as Boise John Waters as Lazarus Joe Carroll as Liam Co Starring Gregory Jones as Wolford Band Member Andy Stein as Wolford Band Member Jon Kellso as Wolford Band Member Clark Gayton as Wolford Band Member Kirsten Wyatt as Mitzi Stewart Cutler as Wolford Band Member Allison Guinn as Bunny Rich Pagano as Wolford Band Member Aaron Heick as Wolford Band Member Jillian Schmitz as Philomena Raven Bowens as Tilly Ivory Fox as Bubbles Matthew Jeffers as Russell Nancy Cantine as Trixie Rosie Cheeks as Sapphira Darien Crago as Sugar Lilin as Lana Jourdan Epstein as Button Club Waitress Dan Berkery as Button Club Band Matt Cusack as Button Club Band Deanna B. Tomasetta as Waitress Alise Morales as Isobel Brian Cali as Bartender Aubree Brown as Annie Oakley Sam Sherwood as Button Club Band Dayne Board as Ringmaster Christopher Jarosz as Button Club Dancer Christopher Jarosz as Greenwich Village Dancer Amanda Lamotte as Button Club Dancer Elyse Niederee as Trapped Door Dancer Marcy Richardson as Trapped Door Dancer Jenna Stocks as Trapped Door Dancer Angeliq Brock as Greenwich Village Dancer Rachel Hospers as Greenwich Village Dancer JD Aubrey Smith as Greenwich Village Dancer Josh Plotner as Button Club Band Sarah Beymer as Button Club Dancer Ariel Ash as Cotton Ball Joli Irvine as Can Can Mademoiselle Alexi Irvine as Gilded Age Tally Sessions as Smartly-Dressed Man Cait Cortelyou as Woman Sarah Elizabeth Hewitt as Secretary Quinn VanAntwerp as Agent Webber Ric Stoneback as Alfred Hitchcock Alex Wong as Button Club Dancer Alex Wong as Greenwich Village Dancer Brady Adair as Another Man Mike Rosengarten as Button Club Band Jordan Sobel as Waiter Loriel Hennington as Trapped Door Dancer