Guest Stars Terry Serpico as Chief Tommy McGrath Beverly D'Angelo as Rebecca Balthus Ryann Shane as Mia Morino Jason Biggs as Detective Andy Parlato-Goldstein Kaili Vernoff as Counselor Albert Jenna Stern as Trial Judge Elana Barth LaChanze as President Rosa Freeman Iliana Garcia as Sarah Franklin Eric Wiegand as Jacob Hoffman Arthur Langlie as Whitaker Yates Avery Cole as Annabel Nelson Colin Trudell as Brad Calloway Trey Fitts as Austin Drake Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration