Guest Stars Jake Cannavale as Caesar Josh Zuckerman as Peter Bart Anthony Ippolito as Al Pacino Patrick Gallo as Mario Puzo Anthony Skordi as Carlo Gambino Joseph Russo as "Crazy" Joe Gallo James Madio as Carmine Annie Funke as Sheila Nora Arnezeder as Françoise Glaser Danny Nucci as Congressman Mario Biaggi Stephanie Koenig as Andrea Eastman Derrick Baskin as Leroy "Nicky" Barnes Michael Rispoli as Tommy Lucchese Mimi Gianopulos as Sue Mengers Co Starring Joe Marinelli as Peter Lovano Matt Gottlieb as Phillip "Benny Squint" Lombardo George Russo as Paul Sciacci Patrick Labyorteaux as Murray Miller Johnno Wilson as Bartender Corey Landis as Stan Kamen