Guest Stars Joseph Hamilton as Merchant Donald Randolph as Dr. Simeon Loving Robert Stevenson as Cutler Harold J. Stone as Judge Elroy P. Greenleaf Leo Gordon as Moley James Anderson as Homer Tom Holland as Hinsdale Uncredited Ray Spiker as Juror Duke Fishman as Juror Mathew McCue as Trial Spectator Fred Aldrich as Juror John Barton as Trial Spectator Chuck Hamilton as Juror Jack Kenny as Juror Ted Smile as Juror