Special Guest Stars Lacey Chabert as Avery Morrison Autumn Reeser as Emma Lowell Guest Stars Kevin McGarry as Peter Hastings Michele Scarabelli as Isabella Serchio Paula Shaw as Gia Jerry Wasserman as Bruce Toby Levins as Finn Matty Finochio as Stanley Gerard Plunkett as Leland Christine Cattell as Sarah Goodwyn Jordana Largy as Carly Serchio Kerën Burkett as Narula's Assistant Justin Singh as Narula Salvatore Vetro as Luigi Roderick Glanville as Carter Kristof Gillese as Oliver