Guest Stars Olivia Luccardi as Lily Day Ben Chase as Nate Swanson Patricia French as Minnie Jesse Scott Egan as Detective Michael Merkel Alice Barrett Mitchell as Cathy Singer Rachael Thompson as Tina Adam David Thompson as Capt. Mike Lang Heather Magee Thomas as Judge Mennemeyer Co Starring Keith Morrison voices Narrator Lara Grice as Cousin Mary Susan Shalhoub Larkin as Luci Michael Hinson as Channel 2 Reporter Dane Davenport as Mike Wood Ricky Catter as Gus Ann Mahoney as Tammy Dickson Obahor as Sean Walker Michael Krikorian as Greg Chatton Lena Clark as Lisa Cindy Pol as Whitney, AP Morgan Roberts as Evan William McGovern as Jim Gralen Banks as Plastic Surgeon Jeff Robins as Juror #2 Merah Benoit as Leah's Daughter