Guest Stars Ben Cockell as Harold Biddle Gillian Vigman as Georgia Biddle Chris Geere voices Slappy Jonathan Silverman as Perry Biddle Samantha Blaire Cutler as Young Eliza William Chris Sumpter as Young Ben Alex Felix as Young Sarah Taylar Hender as Young Nora Michelle Mao as Young Victoria Eddie Jemison as Ephraim Bratt Christine Willes as Madame Zelda Co Starring Natalie Moon as Ms. Dietrich Kaylah Zander as Betsy Andy Thompson as Owner / Manager Jeff Gladstone as Audience Member #3 Lisa Durupt as Rhonda Craig Haas as Real Estate Broker Will O'Brien as Audience Member #2 Abdul Malik Ali as Random Kid Kathleen Keatings as Owner / Manager's Assistant Anthony Demare as Rough Looking Guy Shawn Bordoff as Audience Member #1