Guest Stars Erika Alexander as Abby Alex Goodrich as Bertie Sadieh Rifai as Lakshmi Awad Jason Wells as Ben Christopher Denham as Leo Jenkins Deanna Reed-Foster as Sheila Kevin Gudahl as Detective Shawn Lynsky Nate Burger as Gary Al'Jaleel McGhee as Patient Phil Ridarelli as Sketch Artist Kirsten Fitzgerald as Nurse Josef Co Starring Christopher Meister as Clarence Jimmy Carrane as Senior Reporter Dee Dee Batteast as Teacher