Guest Stars Kylie Liya Page as Cassie Wilkins Ella Rubin as Natalie Gibson Kristin Griffith as Janice Roy Chinasa Ogbuagu as Teresa Adams Scott William Winters as Eric Dawicki Michael Mosley as Joseph Cataldo Kelly AuCoin as Detective Gordon Jeff Wahlberg as Rob Mahoney J.C. MacKenzie as Judge Lawrence Moniz Peter Gerety as Conrad Roy Robert Larriviere as David Correia Co Starring Callie McClincy as Hayden Carter Leah Thompkins as Paige Roy Ella Kennedy Davis as Sydney Roy Melissa Ponzio as Carolyn Christina Bach as Reporter #2 Shaun Lynch as Bailiff Megan Lawless as Riley Anderson Dianna Catterton as Klarmen Nurse #1 Marissa Chanel Hampton as Reporter #1 Karen Aruj as Klarmen Orderly Carrie Weisberg as Alli Stacy Sheets as Courthouse Guard