Guest Stars D'Arcy Carden as Natalie Greer Michael Irby as Cristobal Sifuentes Jessy Hodges as Lindsay Mandel Nick Gracer as Yandar Turhan Troy Caylak as Akhmal JB Blanc as Batir Elsie Fisher as Katie Harris Miguel Sandoval as Fernando Marika Dominczyk as Ana Michael Lanahan as Brian Mark-Paul Gosselaar as Himself Co Starring Michael Andrew Baker as Joel Carmine DiBenedetto voices Taylor Daniel Montgomery as Mike Eliza Shin as Publicist Avital Ash as Madeline Yumarie Morales as Interviewer Monnie Aleahmad as TBD Ashley Porter as Makeup Artist