Guest Stars Darrell Britt-Gibson as Jermaine Jefrint Rightor Doyle as Nick Nicholby Jessy Hodges as Lindsay Mandel Gary Kraus as Chief Krauss Robert Wisdom as Jim Moss Fred Melamed as Tom Posorro James Hiroyuki Liao as Albert Nguyen Laura San Giacomo as Annie Eisner Karen David as Sharon Lucado Vanessa Bayer as Morgan Dawn-Cherry Sal Lopez as Anita's Father Tom Allen as Mitch Co Starring Anthony Molinari as Shane Taylor Jolene Van Vugt as Traci David Castillo as Cal Chris Morrison as TBD Clay Cullen as Robbie Garvin Funches as Mailman Natalia Abelleyra as Anita Ellen D. Williams as Customer Brick Jackson as Kleintop Employee Bob Turton as Mr. Kleintop Lupe Carranza as Anita's Mother Sarah Waisman as Customer Tony Czech as Kleintop Employee Ana Rey as Kleintop Employee Adia Smith-Erikkson as Dealership Employee Parsa Montazeri as Theo Lucado