Special Guest Stars Jensen Ackles as Beau Arlen Guest Stars J. Anthony Pena as Deputy Mo Poppernak Ryan O'Nan as Donno Jamie-Lynn Sigler as Tonya Wallace Vinny Chhibber as Jag Bhullar Zoë Noelle Baker as Phoebe Leyendecker Constance Zimmer as Alicia Corrigan Bernard White as Veer Bhullar Co Starring Brian Landis Folkins as Humbert Monica Sanchez as Janelle