Guest Stars Dallas Goldtooth as Nelson Renville Mimi Gianopulos as Kaitlyn Monica Padman as Melanie Shawn Parsons as Holt Stephen Schneider as Remington Jon Barinholtz as Alden Whitmer Jon Barinholtz as Rye Whitman Jon Barinholtz as Cox Whitley Natalie Ball as Herself Co Starring Dave King as Jeff the Barista Stephanie Escajeda as Maureen Ortega Ernest Tsosie III as Chief Nightpipe Jesse Bush as FBI Agent Kathleen Kenny as Assistant Director Charlie Morgan Patton as Amber Kahara Hodges as Eileen Noah Anselmo as Birch