Guest Stars Aaron Himelstein as Friedman Mageina Tovah as Glynis Figliola Annie Potts as Lt. Lucy Preston Kimberly McCullough as Beth Rinehart Jack Plotnick as The Other Sammy Paul Sand as Rabbi Polonski Mike Starr as Big Tough Guy God Christy Carlson Romano as Officious Hall Monitor God Mary Mara as Sarah Polonski Joanne Baron as Female Guest God Co Starring Charlie Koznick as Ryan Petrea Burchard as Catherine Lee Chayim Frenkel as Cantor