Guest Stars Mona Freeman as Modesty Blaine Buddy Ebsen as Sheriff Scratch Madden Richard Deacon as Floyd Gimbel Robert Griffin III as Bartender Riza Royce as Woman Wendell Holmes as Mayor Uli Bemus Lance Fuller as Faro Jack Norcross Murvyn Vye as Captain Puget Earl Hansen as Mr. Wilkins Uncredited Ray Spiker as Sailor Hank Patterson as Hanrahan Luis Delgado as Man at Auction Lane Chandler as Gibbons Colin Kenny as Poker Player