Guest Stars Rebecca Brooksher as Claire Scott Catherine Wolf as Betsy Scott Zoë Sophia Garcia as Kim Fogelman Shaun Anthony as Joshua Fogelman Jackie Debatin as Sally Sherman Tess Frazer as Darlene Sherman Chris Mason as Walker Hawley Benedict Samuel as Teddy Michael Cram as ATF Agent Lucas Peele Larry Mitchell as Peter Cox Carl Gilliard as Ezekiel Colson Isaiah Dodo-Williams as Donte Colson Co Starring Rivera Reese as Brenda Cynthia Murell as Louanne Cameron Michael Raymond Fox as Murray Lucas Perrotta as Mason Cameron Alex Michael Shafer as Third Man with Martini Zoe Hoffmann as Amber Cameron Ken King as Brad Cameron Donna Winfield as Carla Victor Plajas as State Trooper